5 Mistakes People Make After a Car Accident (That Hurt Their Claim) | The Case Shortcut by JusticeGuys

When a crash happens, adrenaline takes over — and that’s when most claim-damaging mistakes occur.
The reality is: what you do in the hours and days after an accident can make or break your case.

In this edition of The Case Shortcut, we’ll walk you through five common errors people make after a car accident — and how to avoid them so your claim stays strong and fair.

1. Leaving the Scene Too Quickly

Even if the damage looks minor or you feel fine, never leave the scene before law enforcement arrives.
Failing to stay and file a report can lead to penalties, or worse, make it harder to prove fault later.

Do this instead:
Call 911, document everything, and exchange information with all drivers involved. Wait for the official police report — it’s a key piece of evidence your lawyer will need.

2. Admitting Fault (Even a Little)

It’s natural to want to apologize, but even casual phrases like “I didn’t see you” or “I’m sorry” can be used against you.

Do this instead:
Keep the conversation factual and polite. Let the investigation determine fault. Stick to gathering information, not assigning blame.

3. Skipping the Doctor

Many injuries don’t show symptoms right away — neck, back, and internal injuries often appear days later.
When you delay care, insurance companies argue that your injuries weren’t serious or weren’t caused by the accident.

Do this instead:
Get checked out immediately, even if you feel fine. Medical records created right after the accident connect your injuries directly to the crash.

4. Not Documenting the Scene

Photos and witness details are gold for any claim. Once you leave, evidence disappears fast — road conditions change, vehicles are towed, and memories fade.

Do this instead:
Take clear photos of all vehicles, license plates, damage, traffic signs, and road conditions. If anyone witnessed the crash, ask for their contact information on the spot.

5. Talking to the Insurance Company Without a Lawyer

Insurance adjusters sound helpful, but their job is to limit payouts — not protect your rights.
Many people accept a quick settlement that doesn’t cover long-term medical costs or lost wages.

Do this instead:
Consult a lawyer before giving any recorded statement or signing paperwork. The right legal team can ensure you get what your claim is truly worth.

Quick Recap

Avoid these five common mistakes, and you’ll stay ahead of the insurance company’s playbook:

• Don’t leave early.

• Don’t admit fault.

• Don’t skip medical care.

• Don’t forget documentation.

• Don’t face insurers alone.

Protecting your rights starts with the right steps — and JusticeGuys is here to help you take them.

Post-Accident Mistakes That Cost You

A Quick Guide to Protecting Your Car Accident Claim
Download this free checklist to keep in your glove box. Learn exactly what to do (and what not to do) after a crash to safeguard your health and your rights.

Download your free copy today — from the team at JusticeGuys.

If you’ve been in a car accident and aren’t sure what to do next, don’t go it alone.

JusticeGuys connects you with experienced California attorneys who fight for your rights — and you pay nothing unless you win.

Find a Lawyer Now at JusticeGuys.com

FAQs

1. Should I always call the police after an accident?
Yes. Even for small fender benders, a police report helps verify what happened and protects you legally.

2. What if I feel fine after the accident?
Still see a doctor — adrenaline can mask injuries. Having a medical record strengthens your claim.

3. Can I handle the insurance claim myself?
You can, but it’s risky. Insurance companies often pressure unrepresented drivers to settle for less.

4. How long do I have to file a claim in California?
Generally, you have two years from the accident date, but sooner is better — evidence fades fast.

5. What does it cost to hire a lawyer through JusticeGuys?
There are no upfront fees. You only pay if your lawyer wins your case.

justiceguys.com